Before You Cancel That Long-Term-Care Policy, Read This
by Corey Sunstrom, CFP®
Director of Financial Planning
Every so often, a client forwards me a letter from their long-term-care insurance company announcing another premium increase. The message accompanying it is usually some variation of, “Can you believe these people?”
And I get it. Imagine buying a policy twenty years ago, faithfully paying the premiums, never filing a claim, and then being rewarded for your loyalty with another bill that’s 30% higher than last year’s. It’s not exactly the kind of customer appreciation program you’d recommend to a friend.
But these letters are also some of the more important insurance documents we review with clients. An older long-term-care policy can be remarkably valuable, even when the premiums have become difficult to stomach. Before deciding whether to keep it, reduce the coverage, or walk away altogether, we need to understand what the insurance company has actually promised to provide, how likely you are to need it, and whether the contract still makes sense for your situation.
The odds of needing care are higher than most people think.
Research from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services estimates that roughly 70% of Americans who survive to age 65 will eventually develop severe long-term-care needs. About 48% will receive paid care at some point. The gap between those numbers is worth thinking about because much of the care Americans receive never generates an insurance claim or a bill from a nursing facility. It comes from spouses helping spouses, adult children rearranging their lives, or relatives taking turns handling responsibilities that gradually become too much for one person.1
There’s also an important difference between needing care and needing it for a long time.
Federal long-term-care planning estimates put the average duration of long-term-care needs at approximately 3.7 years for women and 2.2 years for men. Women generally live longer, which increases their exposure to age-related conditions that may require extended assistance. And while those averages provide a useful starting point, they tell us very little about the range of possible outcomes. Someone recovering from a stroke might need professional help for six months, while another person living with Alzheimer’s could require increasingly intensive care for many years.2
I also think family history deserves more attention than it typically receives in these conversations. If you’ve watched a parent spend eight years declining from dementia, you’ve probably developed a very different understanding of long-term care than someone whose parents remained independent well into their nineties. Neither experience tells us exactly what your future will look like, but both are relevant when we’re evaluating your exposure to a potentially significant expense.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners recognizes personal and family medical history as factors worth considering when evaluating long-term-care needs. I wouldn’t suggest that a parent’s experience predicts your own, but I’d be equally reluctant to ignore it, especially when we’re discussing an existing insurance policy that may be impossible to replace.3
Why do these policies keep getting more expensive?
To understand what’s happening with traditional long-term-care premiums, we have to go back a few decades, when insurers were selling these policies using assumptions about human behavior that turned out to be rather optimistic.
Insurance companies expected a meaningful percentage of customers to eventually stop paying their premiums. They also underestimated the number of policyholders who would need care and, in some cases, how long those claims would continue. When actual experience failed to match those projections, the financial consequences were substantial.3
The irony is that many policyholders turned out to be considerably more loyal than insurers had anticipated. They kept paying, year after year, until they reached the ages when they were most likely to need the coverage.
Insurers have spent much of the intervening time trying to correct their original pricing mistakes. In certain older blocks of policies, premium increases of 20%, 40%, 60%, or more have occurred, sometimes across multiple rounds. A review of historical regulatory data on older policies reported an average cumulative approved rate increase of 112% across the filings studied. That figure is not a prediction for any individual policy, but it illustrates how dramatically the economics of older contracts can change.45
There is an important protection here, however. Traditional LTC policies are generally guaranteed renewable, meaning an insurer cannot single you out for a premium increase simply because you’ve developed a medical condition. Increases generally apply to a class of similar policies in the applicable state and are subject to state insurance regulation.6
That distinction matters, although I suspect it provides limited comfort when you’re the one writing the check.
Here’s what I find particularly interesting about these older policies. Some may contain benefits, inflation features, or pricing terms that are difficult to obtain in a new policy today. An insurer’s desire to charge considerably more today doesn’t automatically mean the original policy has become a bad deal. It means the contract deserves a policy-level review before we assume either that it should be kept or that it should be surrendered.
What does your policy actually cover?
When a client asks whether to surrender an older policy, I usually begin by reviewing the coverage rather than the premium. There’s a good chance the policy was purchased long enough ago that neither the client nor the original insurance agent remembers every provision, and some of those provisions can make a tremendous difference.
First, we need to understand what qualifies someone to receive benefits. For federal tax-qualified long-term-care treatment, a licensed health-care practitioner generally must certify that the insured is chronically ill. Under the functional-loss route, that generally means the person is expected to be unable to perform at least two activities of daily living without substantial assistance for at least 90 days; severe cognitive impairment can also qualify. Qualified long-term-care services are generally provided under a prescribed plan of care. The actual insurance contract still controls the policy’s benefit eligibility and claims process.7
Then there’s the elimination period, which works somewhat like a deductible but is measured in days rather than dollars. Depending on the contract, the insurer may require 30, 60, or 90 days before benefits become payable. More importantly, some policies count calendar days while others count only qualifying days of care. That difference could substantially change how long someone is paying out of pocket.78
I also want to know whether the policy reimburses actual expenses or pays a fixed benefit once the insured qualifies. Reimbursement policies generally pay eligible care expenses up to a contractual limit, which makes the definition of covered services especially important.7
Consider someone who would prefer to remain at home with part-time professional assistance rather than move into an assisted-living community. A policy that covers home health services generously may be much more useful to that person than one with restrictive home-care provisions, even if both advertise similar maximum benefits.
Inflation protection deserves particular attention. A policy purchased twenty years ago with a $150 daily benefit and 5% compound inflation protection could now provide roughly $398 per day, assuming twenty full years of compounded increases. That is a dramatically different benefit from what appeared on the original application.8
Before surrendering coverage, I’d also want to confirm the remaining benefit pool, whether benefits are available for assisted living and nursing care, whether the policy contains provisions that would be difficult to obtain in a new contract today, and the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the insurer responsible for those benefits.
Does having enough money to pay for care make the insurance unnecessary?
This is where the discussion becomes particularly relevant for clients who have accumulated substantial wealth.
I occasionally hear the argument that once someone has enough investment assets to pay for long-term care, they no longer need insurance. There’s some logic to that, but I don’t think it’s quite so simple.
A household might have more than enough financial resources to handle an extended period of care, yet still prefer to transfer some of that exposure to an insurer. A policy providing several hundred thousand dollars of benefits could preserve assets for a surviving spouse, reduce the likelihood of selling investments during an unfavorable market, or simply provide additional flexibility when a family is already dealing with a difficult situation.
Of course, the opposite can also be true. There are policies where years of premium increases have materially changed the economics, and continuing to pay may no longer make sense given the benefits available and the household’s financial position.
What’s important is that we evaluate the decision looking forward. Past premiums generally should not justify paying an uneconomic future premium simply because the money has already been spent. But prior premiums can affect certain nonforfeiture or reduced paid-up benefits, so we should review the contract before treating those past payments as irrelevant to the options available today.
We also shouldn’t assume that surrendering is the only alternative to paying the full increase. Depending on the contract, an insurer may allow you to shorten the benefit period, reduce the daily benefit, modify inflation protection, or extend the elimination period. Some policies also include nonforfeiture provisions that can preserve a reduced amount of coverage after premium payments stop. Those alternatives may offer a reasonable compromise between maintaining the original contract and abandoning coverage entirely.9
There are tax considerations as well. Benefits from tax-qualified traditional long-term-care policies are generally excluded from federal taxable income, subject to applicable rules and limitations; certain per-diem or periodic benefits can also be subject to federal limits and reporting requirements. Premiums may also qualify as deductible medical expenses within age-based limits, although the actual benefit depends on whether the taxpayer itemizes and meets the applicable deduction requirements.1011
None of this makes the decision particularly easy, but it does make it possible to approach it intelligently.
The policy you own may be worth more than you realize.
I don’t believe every traditional long-term-care policy deserves to be kept indefinitely. Insurance needs change, family circumstances evolve, and premiums sometimes reach a point where the original bargain simply doesn’t hold up anymore.
But I am cautious about surrendering older coverage, particularly when someone’s health has changed since the policy was issued. At an older age or after a health change, comparable new coverage may be unavailable, materially more expensive, or subject to different underwriting and benefit terms. Once an existing contract is surrendered, getting the same coverage back may not be possible.
So if you’ve received another unpleasant letter from your long-term-care insurer, send it our way before making any changes. We can help incorporate the policy into the broader financial plan, compare the cost of maintaining coverage against your ability to fund care independently, and identify the questions that need to be answered. Policy-specific insurance options, such as reducing benefits, changing inflation protection, surrendering coverage, or replacing a policy, should be reviewed with an appropriately licensed insurance professional.
After all, we’ve spent decades watching insurance companies discover that they underestimated the cost of providing these benefits. Before giving up the coverage, I’d like to make sure we understand what the policy is actually worth to your plan today.
Safeguard Your Finances With Pro Guidance
Want to learn more about long-term-care and it’s impact on your finances? You don’t have to navigate this complex terrain alone. Working with an advisor can help you understand your options.